» The Fractal Geometry of Nature

The Fractal Geometry of Nature Reviews

Customer Rating:
Summary: It's OK but....
Comment: Benoît Mandelbrot is unquestionably a great savant but he should have taken some lessons on how to write books.

There is an intense feeling of disappointment after reading this book and it is hard to pinpoint why. It's all there: nature in a wondrous new light. An original work which almost singlehandedly (well... almost) spawned a new field, a field which is not only beautiful but immensely useful as well. The discourse is not too complicated and it is not simplistic pap-science either. Yet there is something missing, a passion or what some might call 'heart'.

When I pick up a book about fractals, even when it is a highly technical work like formal fractal geometry, there is always a certain sense of excitement, of dabbling with a new and beautiful toy. You won't get that feeling with this book.

I still recommend it, in fact I think that it is a must-have if you are serious about this topic, but don't expect too much excitement.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: A seminal work
Comment: Very few books have so many quotes as this one. I am not sure if there is much left to be said, but I know this. For those professionals who still think that fractals are "spurious solutions coming from the discretization of differential equations", should take a closer look to this book. Not only won't harm, but also will show many interesting features about the nature of fractals and the "fractality" of nature, besides the fact that many of them come from *difference* equations, which are not necessarily related to the discretization of a differential equation. This book is based on serious work from many well-reputed mathematicians before Mandelbrot, e.g., Haussdorff, Lyapunov and some others. Although the book does talk about the mathematics behind fractals (wouldn't be so much a book of mathematics if it didn't, but also a philosophical one) and the necessity of coining some new mathematical terms, it also contains so much about history of mathematics, the path that leads towards fractals. As I said, the book is many times quoted, but (without trying to point a firing, accusing finger), there is a difference in quoting a book because it is famous, and another actually reading it, and having enlightenment for our own sake. Certainly I think is a "must-have-it" for most mathematicians, for many physicists, philosophers of science and engineers, but also it wouldn't be a bad guest in the library of any layman, provided the layman overcomes for some minutes the initial "classical" fear to mathematics. I would say this layman won't regret it at all. Mandelbrot does explain most of the concepts practically "ab initio", from the very scratch, including etymology and history as I previously said. One little thing against this book though: it doesn't have so many color plates as some other books on the subject, but it does have all the needed graphics to grasp the concepts.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: Nice coffee table book? Not much else.
Comment: The BOOK by the MAN who coined the name fractal and brought them
to the general public. (Actually an enhanced version of an
earlier book with a slightly different title, same publisher.)

This book has historical value I suppose. But there are now
prettier picture books if you want those or you can easily create
your own. And if you are interested in the maths then you should
definitely look elsewhere (Devaney perhaps?). I think there is a
nice collection of papers by early 20th century pioneers
available too.

Now I wonder is Mandelbrot really the mathematician he is reputed
to be in popular imagination? It seems to me there is little here
that was not thought of before in the early 20th century by
Hausdorff, Poincare, Julia, Lebesgue, Bachelier and others. And
the whole fractal idea seems to have a life of its own in popular
imagination that does not to be justified according to the (much
smaller) importance in physics and other sciences.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: Essential classic book for everyone's library
Comment: Mandelbrot presents unique and infinitely deep look at nature. The emerging theory of interaction shows that his notion of fractal turned to be more fruitful than anyone could guess. Savov's theory of interaction rigorously proves that nature is one self-reproducing and therefore self-similar fractal like interaction. Its oscillating sources remain always finite and synchronize to eject smaller similar ones.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: A dated but still fascinating book
Comment: This was the book that first caught my attention. It was the cover diagram: a figure the like of which I had never seen. One thing led to another until I finally wrote my own application of fractals, Fractals in Music.

Mandelbrot is an odd character, but a superb thinker. His book does not offer a lot of science, but rather a compelling view of how this fascinating and growing topic developed. I recommend it highly.

---

More Reviews for The Fractal Geometry of Nature