» An Imaginary Tale: The Story of "i" [the square root of minus one]

An Imaginary Tale: The Story of "i" [the square root of minus one] Reviews

Customer Rating:
Summary: The square root of minus one and the complex plane
Comment: As electrical engineer and after reading the excellent reviews above, I just can add that

An Imaginary Tale the Story of the sqr(-1),

by professor Nahin, is really a historical proof of how difficult is the evolution of truth, even in science and mathematics, and in this case I mean the complex plane. Without it, for sure, complex numbers would not have the acceptance and applications they have today.

Argand, Buée and Wessel they all recognized the

"geometric understanding of the sqr(-1)"

as it is

"the sign of perpendicularity"",

and professor Nahin wrote:

"This is so important a statement that it is the only mathematical expression in the entire book that I have enclosed"pag53.

Let me add, please that, when dealing with the electromagnetic field, its wave nature, the rotation concept or its correspondent 90 degrees concept are so inherent to it, that we can understand, why complex numbers are for real and are so essential for understanding and representing the physical world, and why it so is important to understand why the sqr(-1) is called the rotation operator, as is recalled by professor Nahin.

This book, the same as Oliver Heaviside is another must-read for all those interested in the evolution of science and physics, which normally have not evolved by what we call today mainstream.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: A Wonderful Book
Comment: This is a wonderful book for those who have studied at least some Maths at a university level. One enjoys delightful and elegant maths without the plodding drudgery of the usual textbooks. Adding to the fun is the historical context in which the results are set.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: First-Rate Introduction to complex numbers
Comment: This is a first-rate introduction to complex numbers. Little background is required to start reading, though a decent high-school background will help.

If you ever wondered what complex numbers were for, if you have forgotten why the number i was created, if you want to learn the art of equation solving, if you are curious about Gauss and Euler, this is the book.

I've read several other books by Paul Nahin, and this one is among his finest.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: Perfect enrichment for math students & teachers
Comment: Teaching mathematics is often an uphill battle against the forces of abstraction and dullness. This delightful book is a perfect antidote, weaving as it does the history, applications and actual mathematics surrounding the concept of "imaginary" and "complex" numbers. But don't get the wrong expectation -- it's a real math book, with equations, proofs, etc, varying in level from high-school algebra and geometry to college calculus and physics.

I myself bought it in a search for material to motivate a bright 11-year-old that I am tutoring. I introduced imaginary and complex numbers to him, but all of the actual applications seemed far out of his reach. So now when I mention imaginary numbers he screws up his face and asks for more boolean algebra instead. But with this book, I now have a number of examples and historical anecdotes to motivate and fascinate him, particularly geometric interpretations and applications.

Here, for example, is one extremely elementary application that I did not know about. Prove: the product of two sums of squares is itself the sum of two squares in two different ways. Symbolically, given any integers a, b, c, d, there are integers p, q, r, s with...

(a^2 + b^2)(c^2 + d^2) = p^2 + q^2 = r^2 + s^2

This was demonstrated by mathematicians a long time ago, but not particularly easily. Using complex numbers, it's almost trivial to see, however, certainly within reach of a student of Algebra I. (There's an even simpler version of the proof that Nahin presents, but it's a bit messy to write without properly typeset mathematics.) This also makes the important point that complex numbers are very useful to help understand non-complex mathematical phenomena, a point Nahin makes throughout the book.

This also illustrates that this is a real math book, not simply a popularization piece ~about~ mathematics and mathematicians. It's really too bad that reviewers who expected the latter are downgrading their ratings of the book, because if you understand and accept what it is trying to be, it's a gem!

Much of this material is, of course, available by searching the internet. But it's not easy to find, and of highly variable quality. So Nahin's book is a real service to teachers and students at all levels.

---

Customer Rating:
Summary: Wonderful book -- very highly recommend it
Comment: A fantastic resource for anyone who has an inclination to learn math with history of how it really developed. I truly felt sorry that I didn't have this book when I was learning Trignometry in high school -- would have used De Moivre's theorem to derive the interesting identities without having to resort to painful coordinate geometry proofs.

ps: this book is not bedtime reading

---

More Reviews for An Imaginary Tale: The Story of "i" [the square root of minus one]